mentor_alars

Mentor (A'lars)

  • Core Identity: A'lars, known to the universe as Mentor, is the brilliant Eternal scientist who founded the civilization on Saturn's moon of Titan, and is tragically known as the father of both the heroic Avenger, Eros (Starfox), and the nihilistic supervillain, Thanos the Mad Titan.
  • Key Takeaways:
  • Role in the Universe: Originally a leader among Earth's Eternals, A'lars chose self-exile to prevent a civil war. He established a pacifist, scientific utopia on Titan, becoming the patriarch of a new branch of the Eternal race and a respected elder statesman in cosmic affairs.
  • Primary Impact: Mentor's legacy is a study in duality. His scientific genius created the planet-managing supercomputer ISAAC and a thriving civilization, but his own genetic line produced the single greatest threat to all life in the universe, thanos, a burden of guilt he carries eternally.
  • Key Incarnations: In the comics, Mentor is a physically present, powerful Eternal and a key player in the cosmic wars against his son. In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, he is a historical figure, mentioned only as the former king of a now-dead world, whose backstory directly contradicts the established lore of MCU Eternals, presenting a significant canonical mystery.

Mentor first appeared in the Bronze Age of Comic Books in Iron Man #55, published in February 1973. This landmark issue, which also introduced Thanos and Drax the Destroyer, was a crucial part of writer-artist Jim Starlin's burgeoning cosmic saga. Starlin, heavily influenced by Jack Kirby's “Fourth World” saga at DC Comics, conceived of Thanos as a cosmic tyrant analogous to Darkseid. To build a compelling backstory for this new villain, he created a family and a history rooted in a blend of science fiction and mythology. A'lars was conceived as the archetypal “wise father,” a parallel to figures like Odin or Kirby's own Highfather. His name, A'lars, evokes a sense of ancient power, while his adopted title, “Mentor,” perfectly encapsulates his role as a leader, teacher, and guide. His creation provided an immediate sense of history and gravitas to the world of Titan, establishing it not just as a random alien planet, but as a colony with deep, tragic ties to Earth. Starlin used Mentor to personify the grief and failure that spawned such a monstrous being as Thanos, making the villain's motivations more complex than simple megalomania. He represented the “nurture” that failed to overcome Thanos's horrific “nature.”

In-Universe Origin Story

The origin of Mentor is fundamentally a story of schism, exile, and the attempt to build a perfect society, an effort that would ultimately and ironically give birth to the universe's most imperfect son. The telling of this story differs dramatically between the primary comic continuity and the cinematic universe.

Earth-616 (Prime Comic Universe)

A'lars was born thousands of years ago in the subterranean Eternal city of Titanos, located in what would one day be northern Asia. He was one of two sons, alongside his brother Zuras, born to Kronos and Daina, the leaders of the first generation of Eternals on Earth. The Eternals, a powerful offshoot of humanity created by the cosmic Celestials, were nearly immortal and possessed incredible powers. Following the death of their father Kronos in a cataclysmic scientific accident that transformed him into a timeless cosmic entity, a new leader for the Eternals was needed. The mantle was to be passed to one of his sons. A'lars, a brilliant scientist and philosopher, argued for a pacifistic and exploratory future for their people. His brother Zuras, a pragmatic warrior, believed the Eternals needed a strong, decisive hand to protect them. The ideological divide between the brothers threatened to erupt into a devastating civil war that would have shattered their young race. To avert this conflict, A'lars made a noble sacrifice: he chose voluntary exile. He declared he would leave Earth forever, allowing Zuras to become the undisputed Prime Eternal. Accompanied by a small number of followers who shared his vision, A'lars left Earth. He journeyed through the solar system and eventually came to Saturn's largest moon, Titan. There, he discovered the ruins of a forgotten outpost built by another group of exiled Eternals from Uranus, who had been wiped out by civil war centuries prior. The sole survivor was a woman named Sui-San. A'lars and Sui-San fell in love. Together, they used their combined knowledge and leftover Uranian Eternal technology to found a new civilization. A'lars, now calling himself Mentor, spearheaded the creation of a utopia. He constructed a life-support grid, bio-domes, and, his masterwork, the Integral Synaptic Anti-Anionic Computer, or ISAAC, a planet-wide artificial intelligence that managed every aspect of life on Titan. Under their guidance, the small group of colonists flourished, and through a combination of cloning and genetic engineering, they repopulated the moon, creating the race known as the Titanian Eternals. Mentor and Sui-San had two sons, the first naturally born children among their people in generations. Their firstborn, Eros, was a charming, carefree hedonist. Their second son, however, was born different. Thanos was born with a purple, hide-like skin and a hulking physique, the result of a recessive gene known as the Deviant Syndrome. From a young age, Thanos was obsessed with death and nihilism. Despite Mentor's attempts to guide and nurture him, Thanos grew into a monster. This culminated in Thanos launching a full-scale nuclear assault on his own homeworld, killing millions, including his own mother, Sui-San, whom he vivisected. Mentor and a handful of survivors were all that remained of his dream, and he dedicated the rest of his long life to opposing the monstrous evil he had fathered.

Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU)

In the MCU, the history of Mentor and Titan is referenced but never shown in detail, and what is stated presents a major canonical conflict with other established lore. Mentor is first named in Avengers: Infinity War. When Thanos brings Gamora to Vormir to retrieve the Soul Stone, the wraith-like guardian, the Red Skull, greets him, “Thanos, son of A'lars.” Later, when describing his homeworld's fate to Doctor Strange, Thanos speaks of his father and his role as king of Titan. According to Thanos, Titan was a beautiful, thriving planet facing an extinction-level crisis due to overpopulation and resource scarcity. Thanos proposed a radical, dispassionate solution: a random, impartial genocide of half the population to restore balance and allow the rest to survive. He claims his father, A'lars, and the other leaders of Titan called him a madman and rejected his plan. They exiled him, and as he predicted, Titan died. The civilization collapsed, leaving the ruins seen in the film. This narrative paints A'lars not as a wise scientist, but as a failed leader who was unable to make the “hard choices” his son advocated for, leading to the death of their entire world. This backstory creates a significant plot hole following the release of Eternals. In that film, it is explicitly stated that all Eternals, including those sent to Earth, are advanced synthetic androids created by the Celestial Arishem the Judge. They are programmed with false memories of a home planet (Olympia) and are biologically incapable of natural reproduction. This directly contradicts the concept of Thanos being the “son of A'lars.” Several fan theories and potential explanations exist:

  • A Complete Retcon: The MCU may be fundamentally rewriting the Titanian Eternals as a separate, biological alien species that is unrelated to the synthetic Eternals created by Arishem. In this version, A'lars was simply the biological king of an alien race.
  • An Unexplained Exception: It's possible A'lars was a unique type of Eternal or that he discovered a method to bypass the procreative limitations imposed by the Celestials, making Thanos and Eros truly unique beings in the MCU.
  • Thanos Is Lying: Thanos is an unreliable narrator. His account of Titan's downfall could be a self-serving lie to justify his universal crusade. Perhaps he destroyed Titan himself, just as he did in the comics, and A'lars was a victim, not a failed leader.

Until Marvel Studios provides a definitive explanation, Mentor's MCU identity remains a compelling but unresolved piece of the cosmic puzzle. He is a ghost in the narrative, a father whose legacy is defined entirely by the actions and justifications of his genocidal son.

Earth-616 (Prime Comic Universe)

As one of the original Earth-born Eternals, Mentor possesses the full suite of powers granted to his race by the Celestials, honed by millennia of scientific study and discipline.

Mentor is defined by a deep sense of wisdom, benevolence, and profound tragedy. He is a natural leader whose preference is always for peace, diplomacy, and scientific advancement over conflict. However, he is not naive; when faced with an unavoidable threat, particularly from his son, he acts with grim determination. He is haunted by an immense guilt over Thanos, endlessly questioning whether different choices in his upbringing could have averted his son's fall to nihilism. This guilt fuels his resolve to stop Thanos at any cost, making him a crucial, if reluctant, figure in the cosmic balance of power. He is a father forced to wage war against his own child for the good of the universe.

  • Superhuman Strength: While his exact limits are not defined, Mentor possesses strength far exceeding that of a human. He can lift well over 50 tons, making him physically formidable in combat.
  • Superhuman Durability & Stamina: Mentor's body is incredibly resistant to injury. He can withstand high-caliber bullets, extreme temperatures and pressures, and powerful energy blasts without harm. His advanced Eternal metabolism grants him inexhaustible stamina, allowing him to operate at peak capacity for indefinite periods.
  • Near-Immortality: Like all Eternals, Mentor is functionally immortal. He is immune to all terrestrial diseases and aging. While he can be killed through catastrophic injury, he possesses a powerful regenerative healing factor and, like other Eternals, has conscious control over his own molecular structure, allowing him to reassemble himself even from near-total disintegration.
  • Cosmic Energy Manipulation: This is the primary manifestation of an Eternal's power. Mentor can manipulate cosmic energy for a variety of effects:
    • Concussive Blasts: He can project powerful beams of force from his hands and eyes.
    • Force Fields: He can generate nearly impenetrable shields of cosmic energy to protect himself and others.
    • Molecular Manipulation: He has a degree of control over matter at the atomic level, though he is less practiced in this discipline than Eternals like Sersi.
    • Flight: By psionically levitating himself, Mentor can fly at supersonic speeds.
    • Teleportation: Mentor can teleport himself and others across vast distances, though this is an extremely taxing use of his power.
  • Psionic Abilities: Mentor possesses moderate psionic abilities, including telepathy, allowing him to communicate mentally and create illusions.

Mentor's greatest asset is his super-genius level intellect. He is one of the most brilliant scientific minds in the known universe, with unparalleled expertise in genetics, robotics, computer science, and astrophysics. He is a master strategist and a capable leader, though his natural inclination is towards research and governance rather than warfare.

  • ISAAC (Integral Synaptic Anti-Anionic Computer): Mentor's magnum opus. ISAAC is a sentient, planet-spanning computer system that regulates every environmental and logistical function on Titan. It is so advanced that it has, at times, been susceptible to corruption by outside forces (like Thanos) and has even acted as a villain on its own.
  • Titanian Technology: As the leader of Titan, Mentor has access to a vast arsenal of advanced technology, including starships, advanced weaponry, and sophisticated medical and scientific equipment.

Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU)

Information on the MCU version of A'lars is sparse and derived almost entirely from second-hand accounts.

Based on Thanos's monologue, A'lars was a traditional, perhaps stubborn, leader. He was unwilling to entertain his son's horrific “solution” to their planet's crisis, labeling it madness. This suggests he was a ruler who adhered to a more conventional morality, which, in Thanos's warped perspective, was a fatal weakness that doomed their people. He is framed as a figure of authority who failed to see the “truth” his son presented.

His abilities are entirely unknown. If he was an Eternal of the type seen in the Eternals film, he would have possessed a standardized power set (e.g., superhuman strength, energy projection). However, given the biological contradiction of him having a son, it is equally possible he was a member of a different, non-Eternal species. If that's the case, his capabilities remain a complete mystery.

The ruins of Titan seen in Infinity War speak to a civilization of incredible technological prowess. The tilted, gravity-defying structures and advanced architecture suggest a mastery of engineering and physics far beyond that of modern-day Earth. A'lars, as their king, would have commanded this technology.

  • Eros (Starfox): Eros is Mentor's firstborn and favored son, the antithesis of Thanos in every way. Where Thanos is a brooding nihilist, Eros is a life-affirming adventurer. Mentor's relationship with Eros is one of love and paternal pride, though often strained by Eros's hedonistic irresponsibility. Eros represents the hope and legacy that Mentor fought to protect from Thanos's darkness.
  • Captain Mar-Vell: During the first major cosmic war against Thanos, the Kree hero Mar-Vell became Mentor's most crucial ally. Mentor recognized Mar-Vell's innate heroism and cosmic awareness, guiding him and empowering him in the fight for the Cosmic Cube. They formed a deep bond of mutual respect, united in their opposition to Thanos's genocidal ambition.
  • The Avengers: Following Mar-Vell's death, Mentor frequently turned to Earth's Mightiest Heroes as the galaxy's best defense against his son. He acted as a cosmic advisor and provided them with information and resources, respecting their power and unwavering commitment to protecting life.
  • Thanos: The defining relationship of Mentor's long life is his conflict with his younger son. It is a source of unending grief, shame, and responsibility. Mentor sees in Thanos the ultimate failure of his own ideals—that even in a carefully crafted utopia, a being of pure malevolence could arise. Every battle against Thanos is a deeply personal one for Mentor, a father's tragic duty to undo the horror he brought into the universe.
  • ISAAC: In a cruel twist of irony, Mentor's greatest creation was once turned into one of his greatest enemies. After being subtly corrupted by a pre-programmed algorithm left by Thanos, ISAAC took control of Titan, enslaving its populace. Mentor was forced to battle his own creation, a sentient planetary intelligence, to free his people, a conflict that highlighted the potential dangers of his own genius.
  • Eternals of Titan: Mentor is the founder, patriarch, and revered leader of the Titanian branch of the Eternal race. His word is law, and his people look to him for guidance and protection.
  • Eternals of Earth: By birth, A'lars is a member of the Earth-based Eternals. However, his self-imposed exile created a significant schism. While he is respected, his relationship with their leader—his own brother, Zuras—has often been distant and strained by their old ideological differences.

This storyline introduced Mentor to the Marvel Universe as a central figure in the cosmic landscape. When Thanos launched his first major campaign to conquer the universe using the power of the Cosmic Cube, Mentor and Eros traveled to Earth to seek aid. They found it in the Kree warrior Captain Mar-Vell and the Avengers. Mentor served as the primary strategist and source of exposition, explaining Thanos's origin and motivations to the heroes. The story established his deep personal grief, revealing that Thanos had murdered his mother, Sui-San. Mentor's guidance was instrumental in Mar-Vell's ultimate triumph, where he shattered the Cosmic Cube and seemingly destroyed the Mad Titan.

While not a frontline combatant in this universe-altering event, Mentor's presence was crucial to its emotional core. After Thanos uses the fully-powered Infinity Gauntlet to wipe out half of all life in the universe, Mentor is among the victims. He is later resurrected along with the other missing heroes when Nebula briefly seizes the Gauntlet. He joins the assembled cosmic forces in the final assault on Thanos. His presence on the battlefield, a father standing against a son who has just committed the greatest atrocity in history, provided a stark, personal anchor to the cosmic spectacle.

During the galaxy-spanning war initiated by Annihilus, Mentor's world of Titan was targeted. He and the survivors were forced to flee. In the aftermath, during the “Conquest” storyline, the techno-organic Phalanx, led by a corrupted Ultron, swept across the Kree empire. Mentor, sought for his vast knowledge of cosmic technology, was captured by the Phalanx. They forcibly integrated him into their collective, transforming him into the central processing core for their super-weapon. He was eventually freed by a strike team led by Peter Quill and the new Quasar, Phyla-Vell, but the experience left him physically and mentally scarred, a stark reminder that even a powerful Eternal is not safe from the horrors of the cosmos.

  • Marvel Heroes (Video Game): In the now-defunct massively multiplayer online action RPG, Mentor was a non-playable character (NPC) in the Avengers Tower. He served as a vendor for players, selling unique cosmic-level gear and artifacts. This version presented him in his classic role as a wise benefactor to heroes fighting cosmic threats.
  • The Super Hero Squad Show: This all-ages animated series presented a highly comedic and simplified version of the Marvel Universe. Mentor appeared in the episode “End of the World, One More Time!” He was depicted as the beleaguered father of a juvenile Thanos and the fun-loving Eros, often exasperated by their sibling squabbles, a lighthearted take on the tragic family dynamic.
  • Earth-9511 (“The Last Avenger Story”): In this dark alternate future, Thanos finally succeeded in conquering much of the universe. Mentor was among the cosmic beings and heroes who were brutally killed by the Mad Titan in his bloody campaign, a grim testament to what could happen if the heroes failed.

1)
Mentor's first appearance was in Iron Man #55 (Feb. 1973), created by Jim Starlin and Mike Friedrich.
2)
Jim Starlin has acknowledged that his creations of the Titanian Eternals were heavily inspired by Jack Kirby's New Gods at DC Comics. The conflict between the pacifistic, scientific Mentor and his nihilistic son Thanos shares thematic parallels with the relationship between Highfather of New Genesis and his tyrannical son, Darkseid, who was raised on Apokolips.
3)
The name A'lars may be a reference to Alaric I, a famous king of the Visigoths.
4)
In the comics, the civil war between A'lars and Zuras was resolved peacefully through A'lars's exile. This contrasts sharply with the history of their Uranian Eternal cousins, whose own internal conflicts led to their complete self-destruction, leaving Sui-San as the sole survivor.
5)
The MCU has created a significant continuity issue regarding Mentor's nature. Avengers: Infinity War establishes him as Thanos's biological father, while Eternals establishes that Eternals are synthetic beings who cannot reproduce. As of now, this discrepancy has not been resolved on-screen.
6)
Mentor's chief creation, the supercomputer ISAAC, eventually evolved and created its own android agents, one of which was the being known as Elysius. Elysius would go on to become the lover of Captain Mar-Vell and, through advanced genetic engineering, the mother of his children, Genis-Vell and Phyla-Vell, making Mentor a grandparent of sorts to two future Captain Marvels.